Since this is Labor Day, it's only fitting that we run an article about how workers' rights are pulverized, and how the government sits on its immobile ass and doesn't do anything about it.
According to the Los Angeles Times, employers are now starting to dock "overweight" workers' pay unless they lose weight (and trying to brainwash employees to accept it). In 2009, for instance, Clarian Health Partners, an Indiana-based hospital chain, will start charging workers up to $30 fortnightly if they fail to meet weight and medical guidelines. This will be one of the most extreme policies anywhere in the nation. (According to Hoovers, Clarian Health Partners is a nonprofit corporation, however.)
I know you're asking if this is even legal. Well, guess what? It ain't. But the law is never an obstacle to Coprorate (sic) America's control freak ways. You have to wonder why the workers are even going along with this, when similar policies have already been ruled illegal: Airlines have already been ruled in violation of the law for firing employees because of their weight.
Aon Consulting's Joe Marlowe says companies are doing this now "because they've run out of other options." Options to do what????? Options to try to keep employees in suspended animation even when they're not at work?
It isn't just corporations (for-profit as well as nonprofit) but also right-wing governments involved in this totalitarianism. In Benton County, Arkansas, workers suffer discrimination regarding their health insurance costs depending on their body mass.
But this may be nothing more than an official admission of what was already an unspoken policy of pay discrimination. A Stanford University study says "overweight" workers are paid an average of $1.20 less per hour than other workers. The report deduces that companies secretly adjust employees' wages to accomplish this discrimination.
Employers' view of workers as company property isn't entirely new. This policy is the progeny of older forms of labor exploitation and servitude. However it's gotten worse again in recent years. Drug testing was bad enough, but this shit has gotten out of hand.
The biggest excuse that Corporate America conjures for this discrimination is that the cost of health insurance is going up too fast. Well, Corporate America is generally against any and all government regulation of the insurance industry (a fact that is obvious from the political candidates it finances), so whose fault is that?
The discrimination and interference in workers' lives is illegal under federal law, but this year, dictator Bush's Department of Labor practically encouraged companies to violate the law by instituting these policies. The verdict against airlines' weight discrimination was confirmation that it's illegal. Since employers' new rules cover a wide variety of conditions that may be classed as a disability, they're also violating the Americans with Disabilities Act, which says companies can't discriminate on the basis of health status.
Naturally, the Los Angeles Times (a paper with a history of union-busting and right-wing bias) only interviewed workers who supported having their rights violated.
(Source: http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-obese29jul29,0,6468472.story?coll=la-home-center)
Monday, September 3, 2007
Corporate America sticks nose into workers' lives
Posted by Bandit at 1:23 AM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
It would be a very good approach to the obesity problem in this country to charge significantly overweight people (and smokers) a higher rate for health insurance than those who live healthier lifestyles. There should be a sliding scale for those who make genuine efforts to get in shape, insurance rates should gradually drop as the weight does.
ReplyDeleteI'll be interested to see if you comment here, Tim, on your boy John Edwards' vow to require all Americans to go to the doctor for checkups if he gets his $120 billion-a-year universal health care plan. We're not going to gloss over this and give Edwards a free pass simply because he's a liberal, are we?
ReplyDeletehttp://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070902/ap_on_el_pr/edwards_2
At first I thought Edwards's idea was bad, then I thought of how it might be good. I have several family members who simply refuse to see a doctor over a cold or flu, and probably haven't been to the doctor for it since about 1987. Their reasoning is that doctors won't do anything anymore, but back in the '70s they always did.
ReplyDeleteAs long as Edwards doesn't start throwing people in jail for not seeing a doctor, I wouldn't be too worried about it. There's so many other things that are mandatory already that people go to jail over that this is nothing in comparison.
Congress changed the definition of "obesity" about 10 years ago...so if the obesity rate is going up, this is probably the whole reason.
ReplyDeleteI don't like the current definition because it makes it sound like it's the person's fault. Being overweight is often caused by genetic factors which a person had no control over.
I also think there should be a "separation of business and health care"...America is the only country where people get their health insurance from their business. Even if we don't have the type of universal health care the rest of the world has, I think insurance ought to be obtained through the government to guarantee that people won't lose coverage if they lose their job.
Charging a different amount based on a person's weight (or docking them pay for it) is discrimination, period.
ReplyDeleteThere are acceptions, but 99% of the time it is your fault if you are fat. It sounds mean but some people just need to be told they need to put down the donuts and get on the treadmill.
ReplyDeleteThere is nothing wrong with making the people who unnecessarily burden the health care system because they can't follow this advice pay the burden of the extra costs. If you want to talk about fairness, why should the healthy man or woman who eats right, exercises regularly and doesn't smoke have to pay for the guy who is 100 pounds overweight, eats artery-clogging fast food 3 meals a day and only gets off the couch to go buy cigarettes?
There are "acceptions", but 99% of the Republican National Committee are known to masturbate to photos of turtles' asses.
ReplyDelete